The New Cartographers

The New Cartographers

Taken from, a great article on the changing map needs:

The New Cartographers

March 18, 2013

“[F]uture shortages in cartography, photogrammetry, and geodesy seem likely because the number of graduates is too small (tens to hundreds) to give NGA choices or means of meeting sudden demand.” —Future U.S. Workforce for Geospatial Intelligence, a report from the National Research Council

Twenty years ago, a driver lost at night would pull his car over, take out a paper map bought at a gas station, and pore over its folds under a dim light. With luck and some critical thinking, he would eventually get where he was going. Today, he’d be more likely to swipe his finger across a smart phone screen and follow directions using Google Maps.

As maps have changed, so have mapmakers. No longer static images, maps have become active interfaces for information exchange, continuously determining where we are in relation to distant satellites and suggesting where we ought to go, says Seth Spielman, a 38-year-old geography professor at the University of Colorado, Boulder. Today, the global geoservices industry collects, shares, and analyzes data on an unprecedented scale. It’s valued at as much as $270 billion per year and employs 500,000 people in the United States, according to a recent report from Google. The rapid transformation, which Spielman equates with a “renaissance” in the field, has overturned traditional ideas of what a geographer does.

CREDIT: Christy Spielman

Seth Spielman

Modern mapmaking

Geographers have traditionally studied how the natural environment contributes to human society and vice versa, whereas cartographers have focused more explicitly on the art and science of mapmaking. Over the past couple of decades, a new field has emerged: geographical information systems (GIS), blending the study and expression of geographic information. Cartography and geography have overlapped and spawned innumerable subspecialties and applications. Modern geographers and cartographers are involved in diverse projects: tracking fleets of vehicles or products, helping customers locate a Dunkin’ Donuts, modeling environmental scenarios such as oil spills, and studying the spread of disease.

Spielman’s career exemplifies the field’s increasingly interdisciplinary nature. When he earned his bachelor’s degree in 1997, he drew maps by hand on sheets of clear acetate and then painstakingly layered and photographed them to create a final product. “I’m pretty sure I was the last generation to do that,” he says. As a graduate student, he worked with the Harlem Children’s Zone to map cases of childhood asthma in Manhattan. Since then, he has applied his skills to ecosystem mapping and criminal justice policy.

A career in demand?

In 2010, the U.S. Department of Labor’s Employment and Training Administration made the first systematic estimates of the size and growth of the modern mapping workforce and divided it into 10 distinct occupations, including GIS scientist and technician and various kinds of surveyors and cartographers. All together, the agency found that nearly 425,000 geospatial professionals were employed in the United States in 2010 and predicted that roughly 150,000 additional positions would be created by 2020.

That’s a lot of new jobs—a 35% increase over 10 years—but for job seekers, landing top jobs may require additional skills in geodesy, a branch of applied mathematics that measures the Earth’s gravitational field, and cartography, as well as a familiarity with fields such as human geography and social media. In January, a National Research Council report commissioned by the National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency (NGA) searched for specific skill deficits that could emerge over the next decade. Since the 2001 terrorist attacks, NGA—one of 16 federal agencies responsible for national intelligence within the Department of Defense—has concentrated its efforts on gathering and interpreting intelligence with a geographical bent. For example, the agency used remote sensing and imagery to map the Osama bin Laden compound in Abbottabad for 2011’s raid.

According to the NGA report, the agency employs about 5000 people with geospatial expertise and hires roughly 300 new recruits each year in five focus areas: geophysics and geodesy; photogrammetry, the science of using photographs to measure objects from afar; remote sensing; cartographic science; and GIS. More recently, the agency has begun to address emerging aspects of geographic intelligence, like social media, that are rapidly turning individuals into on-the-ground sensors.

In its recent analysis, the agency determined that there are more than 2.4 million U.S. citizens capable of working at NGA if they were given substantial on-the-job training. They also found a healthy supply of professionals in GIS, remote sensing, and forecasting. Far fewer people specialize in geodesy, cartography, or photogrammetry, according to the report, making these areas of opportunity for job seekers. “[F]uture shortages in cartography, photogrammetry, and geodesy seem likely because the number of graduates is too small (tens to hundreds) to give NGA choices or means of meeting sudden demand,” the report notes. It also points to skills such as crowdsourcing, human geography, and visual analytics as future requirements for its workforce.

Path to the future

CREDIT: Catherine Spangler

Jeremy White

One limitation for aspiring geographers seeking to acquire these skills is the availability of specialized training programs. Although there are now 189 GIS degree programs in the United States and more than 400 community colleges and technical schools that offer training in geospatial technologies, only a few focus on the advanced analysis and creative, thoughtful presentation of geospatial data involved in cartography. No degree programs exist for photogrammetry.

Some of the most successful modern-day cartographers are at least partially self-taught. Jeremy White learned many of the design skills that landed him his current job as an interactive cartographer at The New York Times as a self-employed designer for his media company, Over 12 years of self-employment, he honed his three-dimensional graphic design and video skills by creating ads for companies like Toyota; now, he applies those skills to projects like the acclaimed New York Times multimedia story “Snow Fall: The Avalanche at Tunnel Creek.”

CREDIT: Catherine Spangler

Tim Wallace

Mapmaking appealed to White as one of the “oldest forms of graphic design,” he says. In addition to working at The New York Times, he is now a geography Ph.D. candidate at the University of Wisconsin (UW) Madison. He says he decided to attend the UW Madison program—one of the few in the country that provides advanced training in cartography—“to learn a trade and apply what I already knew.”

For this new generation of mapmakers and also for their teachers, the biggest challenge is that the technology is constantly changing, says Robert Roth, a geography professor at UW Madison. “The carpet is constantly being pulled out from underneath us,” he says. For Roth, the most important thing for students to learn is to think critically and creatively about how to generalize data. “Mapping has always been an abstraction,” he says. In the past, mapmakers used pen and ink to add and remove information meaningfully, he says. Today, “they write automatic algorithms to filter out detail.”

According to the Google report, the mapping business is expected to grow by 30% annually—an encouraging trend for aspiring geographers. However, the new NGA report suggests that competition for top-tier positions—particularly for GIS scientists and technicians, of whom there is a large and growing supply—is likely to remain fierce. Tim Wallace, a geography Ph.D. student also at UW Madison, says that some of his classmates have struggled to find work after they graduated. However, his training as a cartographer paid off: Like White, he scored his “dream job,” producing maps for The New York Times. Both Wallace and White say that success in their field hinges on a person’s ability and willingness to pick up new skills. The key is “not just to be able to acquire a new computer program,” White says, “but to be able to learn it in 3 weeks.”

Geodesy and photogrammetry

According to the NGA report, the number of recent graduates with training in geodesy and geophysics is in only the hundreds, and the number of recent graduates with training in photogrammetry is in the tens. They’re growing fields, so they are areas of potential opportunity for aspiring geospatial professionals. Below are descriptions of what each specialty involves and some helpful resources. 


Geodesy is the mathematical and physical science of determining the Earth’s size, shape, and orientation through precise measurements of its gravitational field. Applications include showing how the planet’s surface changes over time, including through tectonic activity and sea level change; plotting the trajectories of ballistic missiles and satellite orbits; and making topographic maps and GPS systems more accurate.

Education and training. Few undergraduate programs in the United States teach the mathematics and physics of geodesy as a major; instead, the topic is rolled into broader majors like geomatics—a relatively new, catchall term for the study of geographically linked information—or surveying. Undergraduate training should provide enough background for students to work as geodetic or survey engineers. The Oregon Institute of Technology and Pennsylvania State University (Penn State) are among a handful of colleges that offer that level of training within their surveying and geomatics programs.

Graduate programs in geodesy go into much more depth in mathematics, including least-squares adjustment, Kalman filtering, gravity field theory, orbital mechanics, and the propagation of electromagnetic waves, among other concepts. Students also frequently complete a research project that requires strong computer programming skills. Preparation for these programs could include bachelor’s degrees in survey science, civil engineering, physics, astronomy, mathematics, or computer science. As with the undergraduate programs, master’s and doctorate degree programs in geodesy are few and far between: The Massachusetts Institute of Technology; the University of Colorado, Boulder; and the University of Texas, Austin, all offer M.S. and Ph.D. degrees in geodesy.

Other resources. The National Geodetic Survey, NavtechGPS, The Institute of Navigation, Penn State, and Michigan Technological University all offer standalone professional training programs in geodesy.


Photogrammetry is the science of observing and measuring physical objects and phenomena from film, radar, sonar, or lidar and using multiple overlapping images to create mathematical 3D models of the terrain. Today’s GIS are based on data from photogrammetry.

Education and training. No programs in the United States offer a bachelor’s degree in photogrammetry, and only 15 universities offer photogrammetry classes to undergraduates, according to the NGA report. However, some 2-year professional programs that teach surveying or construction technology may provide hands-on training in using photogrammetric instruments. As with geodesy, a master’s or doctoral degree in photogrammetry provides much deeper knowledge of the mathematics behind photogrammetry, preparing students adapt to technological advances in sensing and combine information from new and multiple sources. Ohio State and Purdue University offer M.S. and Ph.D. programs in photogrammetry; the University of Florida offers a B.S, an M.S., and a Ph.D.

Other resources. The American Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing provides short courses at its meetings on relevant topics. Other organizations that promote skills related to geospatial careers include:

American Geophysical Union

Association of American Geographers

Cartography and Geographic Information Society

IEEE Geoscience and Remote Sensing Society

International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing


University Consortium for Geographic Information Science

Urban and Regional Information Systems Association



Emily Underwood is a staff writer at Science.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.